I’m gay. So what.

by david_demchuk on March 13, 2008

I found the camera cable–or rather, my dear sweet boyfriend found it, in amongst his various electronic cables. Ahem. So the promised pictures are coming very soon.

You know, I take for granted that all of you read the previous paragraph and are still reading, rather than shuddering and fleeing to someone else’s site or closing the browser entirely and rushing away from the computer. I take it for granted and I shouldn’t. When I’m here I don’t even think about whether I’m accepted, “tolerated” or embraced.

There is a video making the rounds. (No, this is definitely not Music to Knit By.) You’ll find it below. I found it, shall we say, insightful.

YouTube Preview Image

Well, wasn’t that bracing! I wish I could say that was shocking or astonishing or mindboggling, but the truth is for middle-aged gay men like me, this is all old news. Sadly. These statements, and the people who make them, seem to have been around since the dawn of time.

I have no rebuttal for this “elected official” (she’s an Oklahoma state representative)–at least none that can be printed here (and I’ve printed a lot here, including things that would make a longshoreman blush). However, a high school student who lost his mother in the Oklahoma City Bombing responded to this video yesterday in a very thoughtful letter, which was picked up by several local news stations. The response is a bit long, but I can’t bring myself to hide any of it behind a link. So please bear with me.

Rep Kern:

On April 19, 1995, in Oklahoma City a terrorist detonated a bomb that killed my mother and 167 others. 19 children died that day. Had I not had the chicken pox that day, the body count would’ve likely have included one more. Over 800 other Oklahomans were injured that day and many of those still suffer through their permanent wounds.

That terrorist was neither a homosexual or was he involved in Islam. He was an extremist Christian forcing his views through a body count. He held his beliefs and made those who didn’t live up to them pay with their lives.

As you were not a resident of Oklahoma on that day, it could be explained why you so carelessly chose words saying that the homosexual agenda is worst than terrorism. I can most certainly tell you through my own experience that is not true. I am sure there are many people in your voting district that laid a loved one to death after the terrorist attack on Oklahoma City. I kind of doubt you’ll find one of them that will agree with you.

I was five years old when my mother died. I remember what a beautiful, wise, and remarkable woman she was. I miss her. Your harsh words and misguided beliefs brought me to tears, because you told me that my mother’s killer was a better person than a group of people that are seeking safety and tolerance for themselves.

As someone left motherless and victimized by terrorists, I say to you very clearly you are absolutely wrong.

You represent a district in Oklahoma City and you very coldly express a lack of love, sympathy or understanding for what they’ve been through. Can I ask if you might have chosen wiser words were you a real Oklahoman that was here to share the suffering with Oklahoma City? Might your heart be a bit less cold had you been around to see the small bodies of children being pulled out of rubble and carried away by weeping firemen?

I’ve spent 12 years in Oklahoma public schools and never once have I had anyone try to force a gay agenda on me. I have seen, however, many gay students beat up and there’s never a day in school that has went by when I haven’t heard the word **** slung at someone. I’ve been called gay slurs many times and they hurt and I am not even gay so I can just imagine how a real gay person feels. You were a school teacher and you have seen those things too. How could you care so little about the suffering of some of your students?

Let me tell you the result of your words in my school. Every openly gay and suspected gay in the school were having to walk together Monday for protection. They looked scared. They’ve already experienced enough hate and now your words gave other students even more motivation to sneer at them and call them names. Afterall, you are a teacher and a lawmaker, many young people have taken your words to heart. That happens when you assume a role of responsibility in your community. I seriously think before this week ends that some kids here will be going home bruised and bloody because of what you said.

I wish you could’ve met my mom. Maybe she could’ve guided you in how a real Christian should be acting and speaking.

I have not had a mother for nearly 13 years now and wonder if there were fewer people like you around, people with more love and tolerance in their hearts instead of strife, if my mom would be here to watch me graduate from high school this spring. Now she won’t be there. So I’ll be packing my things and leaving Oklahoma to go to college elsewhere and one day be a writer and I have no intentions to ever return here. I have no doubt that people like you will incite crazy people to build more bombs and kill more people again. I don’t want to be here for that. I just can’t go through that again.

You may just see me as a kid, but let me try to teach you something. The old saying is sticks and stones will break your bones, but words will never hurt you. Well, your words hurt me. Your words disrespected the memory of my mom. Your words can cause others to pick up sticks and stones and hurt others.

Sincerely

Tucker

I think that says what needed to be said, and by just the kind of person who needed to say it. If this kid had a college fund, I’d be donating.

{ 61 comments… read them below or add one }

Sheri March 31, 2008 at 8:32 pm

Wow. Did I ever get an education here today! I was simply looking at Knitty when I read your article, fabulous by the way, when I ended up at your blog. I read about you knitting for you boyfriend and thought how lucky he is to have you knit for him, then I listened to that video from Hell. I can’t believe that came from an educated elected official. I know that I should never be shocked by people, but I continue to be. I have always said that I accept all people and everyone has rights and freedoms. No one is WRONG, until they say that they are better than someone else, that is wrong. Plain and simple. Keep knitting and loving, that is what is good in life.

Chloe- Scotland UK April 4, 2008 at 11:39 am

Oh my. That woman really needs to see a shrink!
Whether some one is gay or not doesn’t determine his or her lifespan!
It saddens me that she thinks that it is acceptable to call people “gays”. So what if you love a member of the same sex, love should be celebrated, not hate.
Homophobes are afraid of love and hate the fact that there are others that are proud to say who they love out loud.

It shouldn’t matter whether you are gay, lesbian, straight or transgendered; as long as you are happy in being yourself then you are set for the world.
And it really shouldn’t matter if a child is being adopted by a same sex couple as the child will still be loved and will grow up with an understanding that any kind of love is allowed between two people.

I could go on forever here, its a subject I have alot of views on :)

Chloe

Kathy Herzog April 7, 2008 at 2:56 pm

Even though I have been “out” since the late 80s and married to my partner of 20 years just last year I still find myself shocked by this State Rep.’s words (sometimes confronting prejudice is like GroundHog Day–every time is a brand new experience) The whole thing makes me want to stay firmly planted in Massachusetts (although Canada looks good sometimes). I’m new to your blog (but old to knitting) and enjoy it…I wish some men would join our knitting/spinning group, and I wish we could all manage to be more accepting and less judgmental of each other. Loving kindness would be nice. Silence does equal death…Knit on…!

Kathy April 8, 2008 at 5:38 pm

My reaction to these unselfconscious and openly homophobic statements always remind me of that movie Ground Hog Day–same content time after time, and I am always stunned in my surprise and gullibility that people can wield that much hate! This person’s beliefs verge on paranoid psychotic ideation.

I recently came upon your blog on the Knitty site, and my partner/spouse and I got a good chuckle over your most recent entry–the one I am commenting on is more sobering. Selfishly, it makes me even more glad to live in Massachusetts, and be protected by rights that most other same sex couples in this country do not enjoy. However, Silence does equal Death, and it is no good resting on the laurels of same sex marriage in only one state. I’m straining to connect this with the subject of knitting, but this connection eludes me. Thanks for posting this You Tube recording on your blog.

Kim April 8, 2008 at 8:36 pm

Like so many others I found your blog through Knitty. I find your writing to be touching, funny, and insightful. Thank you for posting both the video and Tucker’s response. My best friend is gay and is from Oklahoma. He grew up in a small town close to the Texas border. He grew up with this kind of thinking in his culture. He was convinced Jesus would make him straight if he just believed hard enough. His wife knew he had “feelings” toward men but thought through Jesus they could overcome these “unnatural instincts” He had the “love the sinner, hate the sin” message in his Church. He hated himself for being gay. (He is now married to a wonderful man) Unfortunately, in this day and age people like Rep. Kern continue this message of intolerance, fear, and hate. It is a modality of thinking I cannot wrap my head around because I dont understand how someone can live their life with so much hate and anger in their heart. David, I enjoy your blog and none of your readers care what you do in your bedroom just so long as you are loved.

Cadi April 16, 2008 at 10:32 pm

Glad I found your blog! :-)

Andres P. Nevarez April 17, 2008 at 11:37 pm

Great Video and the letter is even better. That’s right, NOWADAYS you have to watch what you say because we will post it on the internet so that Everyone can hear what you said. Thanks you for Posting this

Cheers

Andy

Jake W May 16, 2008 at 11:11 am

Wow, as someone from Oklahoma, I’m shocked by this speech. I love Oklahoma, and could never imagine staying away for to long, but this is tuerrible. I never thought I’d hear somthing this crass, and rude. I’m straight, conservatice, and Christian. Even though we all don’t agree, shouldn’t we love each other, not despite of our differences, but through them. God bless!

david_demchuk May 16, 2008 at 3:24 pm

Oh yes, Sally Kern’s a charmer–and she’s still at it. (http://www.tulsaworld.com/news/article.aspx?articleID=20080515_16_A5_spancl887904)

I have to admit, I have no idea what “special rights” gays and lesbians are seeking. My understanding is that they/we are trying to get the same rights as heterosexuals. Nothing special there.

I’m also fascinated by this whole “changeable” thing. As someone who has a South Asian Muslim boyfriend, let me tell you, I’ve met many many men (and a few women) who would give anything or do anything to change their sexuality. For them to be discovered by their families or communities means derision, shunning, exile from their loved ones, access denied to their children and, depending on what country they’re in or from, imprisonment, torture and death.

Sexuality is not changeable–at least not in the way that she is asserting. Homo- and heterosexuality are established before birth or very shortly after. Being gay is not a “disease” that can be cured, it is not a “disorder” that can be treated, it is not a notion or a whim. It is what it is.

It is possible for someone like me to marry, to have children, to live in a community that accepts me at face value, to go to a church and pray to a God that I’m told hates the me that I hide deep inside–hates me the way everyone around me would if they knew the truth. That is not “changing” your sexuality. That is denying your sexuality.

It is also possible to experience one’s sexuality as a growing, changing thing that may involve experiences with the same gender or the opposite gender. One can even have sustained relationships on this basis…but, generally, once the relationships are over, the compass needle returns to the direction of its main attraction. This doesn’t mean that homosexuality is changeable any more than heterosexuality is. Individual encounters, even individual relationships, do not necessarily reflect the spectrum of one’s sexual desires and actions.

There are very few truly bisexual people–that is, people who are equally attracted to both men and women, and who can have satisfying sexual and emotional relationships with both genders. Usually, you’re attracted to one gender more than another. And that’s the big clue.

So: sexuality–not changeable. But there is something that can be changed that can help resolve all this tension, frustration, anger and hatred. Bigotry is changeable. You’re not born with it. You don’t acquire it within weeks of your birth. It takes years to develop.

But the good news is, it’s reversible. It’s a disease that can be cured, it’s a disorder that can be treated. All you have to do is change your mind.

Camille June 19, 2008 at 3:57 pm

Being raised in East TN and Penecostal christian, this hatethink still makes my stomach churn and breathing shallow. As the child of a miserable, closeted gay man and the sister of wonderful confident gay brothers, I fight for ALL of us to have those rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.

Thank you David and your partner for your eloquence and candor. The awesome knitting tips are also priceless.

Sewnsew June 20, 2008 at 12:52 am

I’m a 45 year old lesbian and it is the same kinda stuff we hear over here, too. It is frightening.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: